Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Marquette: Christianity Has Been Reduced To This.

T-shirts don't reflect "Faith Doing Justice"
By Staff Editorial

Mission Week. It's a time when we are supposed to step back and reflect on our roles as Jesuit university students in today's society. This year's Mission Week theme was "Faith Doing Justice," which, according to the Mission Week Web site, reflects
"our commitment to a Marquette education that integrates intellectual rigor, spiritual depth and concrete action for a more just and peaceful world."
We especially find this commitment to concrete action and activism interesting. Every day we see students living out the Jesuit mission by participating in service learning, volunteering with Midnight Run, or organizing student teach-ins and seminars for their peers, to name a few areas. This is also apparent in groups we see around campus such as JUSTICE and Ubuntu that promote social justice and emphasize the importance of fair trade. In addition, university coffee vendor,
Stone Creek Coffee Roasters offers fair trade and socially responsible options at all of the Brews on campus.
In light of all this work for justice, we found it quite bewildering that it is unclear whether the T-shirts being sold during Mission Week with the "Faith Doing Justice" logo were fair trade and sweatshop free. The T-shirts were ordered through Piranha Promotions, a company based in New Berlin, Wis. According to Stephanie Russell, executive director of University Mission and Identity, because the university considers Piranha Promotions a preferred company, it was assumed all orders would be free trade and sweatshop free.
However, the T-shirts were produced by Fruit of the Loom, a company known for having sweatshop factories in El Salvador.
Having students walk around in T-shirts with the words "Faith Doing Justice" on the front, that are not free trade or sweatshop free is grotesquely hypocritical, and an obvious poor representation of the phrase. We are sure that the sponsors of Mission Week had good intentions when deciding to sell these T-shirts. It should be noted that it is admirable that all profits will go to La Sagrada Familia, the Milwaukee Archdiocese's sister parish in the Dominican Republic. But Mission Week was not a time for the university to cut corners.
Special attention should have been given during this time to make sure T shirts were made in a fair and ethical environment
in order for Marquette to "walk the walk" in addition to just "talking the talk." By failing to do so, there was a lack of "faith doing justice."
Link (here)

3 comments:

Marco da Vinha said...

A little sidenote: perhpas Jesuits that go around clamouring for socila justice should learn a little more about economics. The "fair price" argument comes to mind. If I'm not mistaken, it was a Jesuit who first coined the term (either it was a Jesuit or someone of another Catholic order, of that much I'm certain), way back when, before Adam Smith even. Roughly put, it was (and still is, wrongly) said that a fair price for a given good could be calculated taking into consideration the producer's labor and expenses (profit was not considered). This would yield the minimum price of the good.

Yet this approach is wrong. Prices are set by the value of a good, yet goods don't have an intrinsic value - people asign value to goods. Hence, prices tend to reflect the consumers' value of the product (why else does a shirt which simply has some fancy brandname on it cost so much more than a "regular" shirt, for example?).

Just some food for thought.

Joseph Fromm said...

That was St. Robert Bellermine, S.J.

testsjmg said...

Incidentally, the hoops that must be jumped to earn a "fair trade" designation are a Socialist Hit Parade and have suprisingly -- or not, depending on how cynical one is -- little to do with paying people a decent wage and offering working conditions consistent with human dignity.

-J.